Business

/

ArcaMax

Econometer: Is Jensen Huang, former Nvidia CEO, irreplaceable?

Phillip Molnar, The San Diego Union-Tribune on

Published in Business News

One of the world’s most valuable companies, California-based Nvidia, recently ousted its CEO Jensen Huang, who some say was irreplaceable.

There have been several major American companies that have lost CEOs that were considered indispensable: Steve Jobs at Apple, Travis Kalanick of Uber and others. In many of these cases, examined by The Wall Street Journal, the companies saw considerable success after an initial dip when charismatic CEOs left.

Nvidia may be different because it reportedly had no real succession plan, the ouster was very abrupt, and the company could be facing federal investigations linking Huang to an alleged Chinese spy.

An editor at Barron’s wrote a different perspective: “When the bad news is all out, when the investigations are all done, and when an inevitable new leader is named, Nvidia will go back to making chips. And the world will need them as much as it did last week.”

Question: Is Jensen Huang irreplaceable?

Economists

Kelly Cunningham, San Diego Institute for Economic Research

NO: Companies inevitably move through life cycles, from inception and startup to growth and maturity. At any point, the company may fail, merge or be acquired. Capabilities of an innovator and founder may not transfer at each stage as focus transitions and differing priorities emerge: expansion and increasing sales, optimizing operations and costs, adapting to customer desires and retention. The right successor — often a veteran operator more than a visionary — needs to be unafraid of making uncomfortable changes.

Alan Gin, University of San Diego

NO: Nvidia has strong momentum in terms of its business. Its third-quarter results were strong, and its outlook is positive. The demand for its chips remains high amid AI development. The company still has thousands of engineers working on future generations of AI hardware. Huang set the strategic path that the company is well positioned to follow. He had shifted to being an advocate for AI in general, which he might still be able to do.

James Hamilton, UC San Diego

NO: Many people thought Steve Jobs, with his amazing vision for innovation, was irreplaceable. But Apple’s sales have quadrupled in the 15 years since Jobs died. Replacing Huang will be more challenging. Huang played an unusually central role in strategy, management and international dealmaking. But Nvidia today has a dominant position in a key industry. That will take more than one man’s mistakes to tear down.

Norm Miller, University of San Diego

NO: Jensen Huang is irreplaceable in the short run because his lean, highly centralized decision-making enabled Nvidia to react quickly and strategically to market and technological changes. Unlike Steve Jobs, who prepared a visible successor, Huang has not groomed a widely recognized replacement. In the long run, however, all leaders are replaceable. A transition to a more committee-driven culture will slow Nvidia’s speed and innovation, but it might also provide stronger governance and oversight.

David Ely, San Diego State University

NO: The sense that Jensen Huang is irreplaceable is due in part to heightened challenges arising from Huang’s abrupt exit coupled with the lack of succession planning at the company. But Nvidia is still a strong company with products that are in high demand, a highly skilled workforce and strong earnings. The transfer to new leadership may be rough, but Nvidia’s strengths will give the new CEO time to transition into the leadership role.

Ray Major, economist

NO: This transition will be risky, but history has taught us that no one is truly irreplaceable. Throughout history, dozens of visionary founders have had successful leadership transitions of their companies, including Henry Ford, J.D. Rockefeller, Ray Kroc, Bill Gates and Steve Jobs. Although Jensen Huang’s departure is abrupt and not a typical transition, there are many others in the tech world who are qualified to take the reins and continue leading Nvidia.

 

Caroline Freund, UC San Diego School of Global Policy and Strategy

NO: No one is. If AI is as transformational as its proponents claim, Nvidia will do fine, and an AI agent can run it until a new CEO is found. If Nvidia’s dependence on Chinese demand and its circular financing of U.S. clients prove unsustainable, Huang’s departure may simply hasten a reckoning already in the making. Either way, he is replaceable.

Executives

Jamie Moraga, Franklin Revere

NO: As much as someone wants to believe they’re irreplaceable, they aren’t. A departure or death could cause turmoil without a succession plan. Strong leadership, an essential product or service, and solid infrastructure should help a company weather the storm. Huang’s intelligence and talent built Nvidia into a trillion-dollar company, but his poor personal decisions have cast a shadow on it, with national security implications. Now Nvidia must navigate scrutiny, public criticism and uncertainty about what information may have been compromised.

Mark Kersey, San Diego County Taxpayers Association

NO: No single founder, executive or employee is irreplaceable, including Jensen Huang. However, some are clearly more influential than others, and the abrupt loss of a rock star founder like Huang hurts Nvidia more than, say, the planned retirement of Tim Cook at Apple a few months ago. Nvidia will recover, either by recruiting a well-known outsider or promoting from within, and companies around the world will continue buying its chips.

Phil Blair, Manpower

NO: No one is irreplaceable. In fact, in human resources, we are often pleasantly surprised when a key staff member’s replacement turns out to be better than the original employee. This may be the case at Nvidia.

Gary London, London Group Realty Advisors

NO: In fact, Huang’s replacement will be unfettered by a relationship with Trump, Chinese spies or personal ego. There appears to be more to this story than meets the eye. This firm and its products are critical to the future of AI and cannot be exposed to foreign threats without a negotiated path to move forward. Nvidia and the U.S. are better positioned to negotiate solutions now that he is gone.

Bob Rauch, R.A. Rauch & Associates

NO: No executive is truly irreplaceable. While Jensen Huang has been instrumental to Nvidia’s success through his vision, leadership and long-term strategy, great companies survive by developing deep talent and succession plans. While his departure could create short-term uncertainty and investor concern, Nvidia’s value ultimately rests on its people, technology, customer relationships and culture, not on any single individual. Exceptional leaders matter, but no one is indispensable.

Austin Neudecker, Weave Growth

NO: Nvidia’s situation is precarious. Jensen’s vision and leadership were instrumental in building the company into a global powerhouse. His abrupt departure creates substantial uncertainty. At this stage, Nvidia’s success rests on its exceptional engineering talent, technology ecosystem, unique customer relationships and dominant market position. Together, these provide a formidable foundation for potential continued growth. Yet, finding a successor with Huang’s strategic instincts will prove difficult, especially while navigating investigations.

Chris Van Gorder, Scripps Health

NO: As a co-founder, Jensen Huang may be the closest thing to irreplaceable in corporate America today. He may be very difficult to replace, but no individual should be indispensable to an institution. Great leadership isn’t just what someone accomplishes while in charge. It’s whether the organization continues to thrive after that person leaves. But I guess Nvidia will find out.


©2026 The San Diego Union-Tribune. Visit sandiegouniontribune.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus